Vitamin D3 Supplements
Vitamin D3 deficiency symptoms and vitamin D3 supplement information
Michelle Goody, PhD
10/1/20266 min read


TL;DR
Vitamin D is a master regulator of inflammation, inhibiting pro-inflammatory pathways and promoting anti-inflammatory ones. It also balances calcium and phosphorus levels.
If you’re struggling with chronic inflammation, you’re very likely deficient in vitamin D. Testing is pretty easy and inexpensive, so test if you’re able. Make sure the test is for 25-hydroxyvitamin D. You don’t need to wait for results to start supplementing.
It’s virtually impossible to get enough vitamin D from sunlight and food alone to correct a deficiency. Start supplementing.
Not all vitamin Ds are created equal. Make sure you’re supplementing with vitamin D3, not D2, and that your D3 supplement also contains vitamin K2.
Vitamin D has such an important role in signaling to other cells that it’s now thought of as a hormone rather than just a nutrient. It signals to kidney, immune, bone, and brain cells, among others. Lower levels of vitamin D correlate with cancer, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, immune system/inflammatory diseases, psychiatric disorders, and more (doi: 10.14336/AD.2016.1021).
Vitamin D also increases absorption of calcium and phosphorus in the small intestine and raises their levels in the bloodstream. Vitamin K2 (and weight lifting) helps make sure the calcium and phosphorus in your bloodstream go to and stay in your bones rather than getting deposited in soft tissues, like arteries. Consult with your doctor before supplementing with vitamin K2 if you are on a blood thinning medication.
Why are so many of us deficient in vitamin D? About 75% of Americans have insufficient or deficient levels (below 30 ng/mL), including about 35% who are deficient (below 20 ng/mL). The percentage of Americans with insufficient vitamin D is increasing over time and is higher in the elderly and in people with darker skin (doi: 10.1001/archinternmed.2008.604).
The majority of vitamin D in the body comes from sunlight hitting the skin, which turns a cholesterol-like molecule into vitamin D through a series of reactions. A smaller amount comes from food. The only food sources worth noting are fatty fish, egg yolks, liver, and certain mushrooms. Some foods are fortified with vitamin D3, such as cow’s milk and cereal grains, but those are two of the most inflammatory foods out there. Increasing your inflammation to get more vitamin D3 is not the best way to raise your levels.
It’s no wonder, with our modern lifestyle and diet, that vitamin D levels are trending down and more and more people are becoming insufficient or deficient. We’re spending more time indoors during daylight hours and shielding our skin from sunlight with sunscreen and UV-blocking clothing. The modern American diet also contains very little fish, liver, and mushrooms. Supplementing with optimal formulations of vitamin D has therefore become a necessity for many people today, especially those with chronic inflammation.
Symptoms of vitamin D deficiency and insufficiency: Listen to your bones, energy, and immune system. While inadequate vitamin D is rarely severe enough anymore to cause the bone softening, weakening, and bending that lead to a diagnosis of rickets (children) or osteomalacia (adults), shin bones that hurt when you push your thumb into them or frequent shin splints can be more subtle signs of bone weakening from vitamin D insufficiency. Or maybe you have general, whole-body fatigue, pain, and/or low mood. Or maybe you catch every cold or flu going around. You may be vitamin D insufficient with no noticeable symptoms at all, which is one reason testing might be a good idea.
Should you get your vitamin D level tested? If you can, yes. It’s a blood test that can be ordered by your doctor and may even be covered by your insurance. If your doctor won’t order it or your insurance won’t cover it (my insurance wouldn’t cover my latest test because I didn’t have a recent history of vitamin D deficiency), you can order direct-to-consumer tests. I’ve done both the Everlywell (finger prick) and Jason Health (venipuncture) tests. They cost about $65-80 each. Make sure you or your doctor orders the 25-hydroxyvitamin D (calcidiol) test and not the 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D (calcitriol) test. The 25-hydroxyvitamin D test measures your full-body stores of vitamin D rather than the active hormonal form. Levels of the active form are tightly regulated, so you could be deficient and still have a normal 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D result. Less than 20 ng/mL is deficient, 20-30 ng/mL is insufficient, 40-80 ng/mL is the ideal range you want to be in, and over 100 ng/mL is too high.


If your doctor won’t order a 25-hydroxyvitamin D test and you can’t afford one or don’t want to order one yourself, it’s a reasonable, educated guess that you’re vitamin D insufficient or deficient if your shin bones hurt when you push on them, you get shin splints, or you’re chronically ill. If that's the case, start supplementing.
Why not try to fix vitamin D insufficiency with food alone? You should absolutely eat vitamin D-rich foods, but it’s unlikely you’ll meet your daily requirement, and it’s virtually impossible to refill depleted stores with food alone.
Fatty fish, liver, egg yolks, and certain mushrooms are among the least inflammatory food sources of vitamin D. These are strong tastes that have fallen out of favor in most modern diets. If you tried to get vitamin D from these foods alone, you’d need to eat a 3 oz serving of fatty fish every day to meet the RDA of 600 IU. That would only prevent a vitamin D deficiency disease like rickets. It wouldn’t prevent insufficiency or raise depleted levels. To get from food alone the amount of vitamin D I’ve taken in daily supplements for years, I’d need to eat 50 oz (3 pounds 2 ounces) of salmon every day. Trying to raise your levels with fortified milk or cereal grains isn’t a good idea for chronically ill people because those foods increase inflammation.
Is there clinical evidence that vitamin D supplements raise the level of vitamin D in the body? Yes. Both vitamin D2 and vitamin D3 raise blood levels of 25-hydroxyvitamin D, but vitamin D3 is more potent and effective at doing so (doi: 10.3945/ajcn.111.031070). My 25-hydroxyvitamin D measured 16 ng/mL when I was at my sickest. I’ve been supplementing with 5,000-10,000 IU of vitamin D3 (with K2) daily for over 10 years, and that has kept my 25-hydroxyvitamin D between 50 and 66 ng/mL on all subsequent tests.
What form of vitamin D supplement should you take, and how much?
Form: D3 is more effective, so you can skip the D2. You can even get a vegan form of vitamin D3 from lichen, if you'd "like-in". Choose a vitamin D3 supplement that also contains vitamin K2. If your D3 doesn’t contain K2, you're not optimizing for bone strength. Vitamin D3 increases the absorption of calcium and phosphorus into the bloodstream, and vitamin K2 helps direct that calcium and phosphorus to bones. Without K2, the extra calcium from D3 supplementation could get deposited in soft tissues, like arteries, and make health problems worse. I’ve tried vitamin D3 + K2 in both sublingual drops and pill form. In my experience, the sublingual drops raised my 25-hydroxyvitamin D to a higher level than the pills did (even at a lower dose), although both forms were effective at raising and keeping my level in the desired range of 40-80 ng/mL. Multivitamins usually contain only about 400-1,000 IU of vitamin D2 or D3, so you’ll want a separate supplement at a higher dose to raise your vitamin D levels.
Dose: This is where testing can help you find the form and dose that get your level between 40-80 ng/mL and keeps it there. As a general guideline, you’re probably not going to raise your levels if you take an average of less than 2,000 IU daily. Some people like to take a megadose, such as 50,000 IU once per week, which can be effective, but I personally prefer daily doses. Megadosing vitamin D should be done under the supervision of a doctor. In my experience, sublingual drops require a dose around 2,000-5,000 IU per day to stay in the optimal range. In pill form, I require a dose around 5,000-10,000 IU per day to stay in range. Since vitamin D is fat-soluble, overdose is possible. Symptoms of overdose are generic gastrointestinal and neurological symptoms that would be hard to attribute to excess vitamin D. If you aren’t going to test regularly while supplementing with vitamin D3 + K2, consider not exceeding doses of 4,000 IU of vitamin D3 if taking it daily and consistently for long periods of time.


Vitamin D3 supplements I have personally taken:
Vitamatic ADK Pills
Codage Vitamins ADK Pills
Carlyle Vitamin D3 K2 Drops
Pure THERAPRO Rx Vegan Vitamins A, D3, K2 Drops
SBR Nutrition Max Absorption Vitamin D3 + K2 Drops
Maxx Labs Vitamin D3 K2 Drops
Live Wise Naturals Vitamin D3 K2 Drops
The supplements listed above are gluten-free, rice-free, dairy-free, and haven't triggered my histamine intolerance.